| 1992 | Parris Duffus | G |
| 1991 | Dan Ratushny | D |
| 1987 | Joe Nieuwendyk | F |
| 1986 | Doug Dadswell | G |
| Joe Nieuwendyk | F |
| 1983 | Darren Eliot | G |
| 1982 | Brian Hayward | G |
| 1979 | Lance Nethery | F |
| 1978 | Lance Nethery | F |
| Pete Shier | D |
| 1974 | George Kuzmicz | D |
| 1972 | Larry Fullan | F |
| 1971 | Kevin Pettit | F |
|
| 1970 | Dan Lodboa | D |
| 1969 | Brian Cornell | F |
| Ken Dryden | G |
| Bruce Pattison | D |
| Pete Tufford | F |
| 1968 | Brian Cornell | F |
| Ken Dryden | G |
| Bruce Pattison | D |
| Walt Stanowski | D |
| 1967 | Ken Dryden | G |
| Doug Ferguson | F |
| Harry Orr | D |
| 1966 | Doug Ferguson | F |
|
